Card Regrade Calculator
Should you crack your slab and resubmit? Find any card, enter its current grade, and see the expected profit or loss from regrading.
Step 1: Find Your Card
Step 2: Current Slab
Step 3: Regrade To
Frequently Asked Questions
What does "crack and resubmit" mean?▾
Cracking and resubmitting is when you remove a graded card from its protective slab (case) and submit it to the same or a different grading company for a new grade. Collectors do this to upgrade a grade (e.g., PSA 9 to PSA 10), switch companies (e.g., CGC to PSA for higher resale), or challenge a grade they believe was too low. It involves cracking costs ($5-15), grading fees ($18-150+), and risk of receiving the same or lower grade.
How are regrade probabilities calculated?▾
Regrade probabilities are based on historical patterns from the grading hobby. Key factors include: current grade (higher grades like 9 have more upgrade potential than 6), source company standards (BGS 9.5 crosses to PSA 10 at roughly 60-70%), card condition consistency, and grading company tendencies. PSA is generally considered slightly more lenient on centering, while BGS is stricter with half-grade precision. These are estimates based on community data, not guarantees.
When is regrading worth it?▾
Regrading is worth it when the expected value gain exceeds total costs. The best candidates are: high-value cards where a one-grade bump means hundreds or thousands in added value, BGS 9.5 cards crossing to PSA 10 (where PSA 10 commands a significant premium), cards you believe were undergraded, and cards from less popular companies (CGC/SGC) moving to PSA for wider market appeal. Avoid regrading low-value cards where costs exceed potential gains.
What are typical cracking and grading costs?▾
Cracking a slab yourself costs $0 but risks card damage. Professional cracking services charge $5-15 per card. Grading fees vary by company and service level: PSA Economy ($18-20, 60-90 days), PSA Regular ($50, 30 days), PSA Express ($100, 15 days). BGS Standard ($22, 40-60 days), BGS Quick ($40, 20 days). CGC Standard ($20, 40-60 days). SGC Standard ($20, 30-45 days). Plus return shipping ($10-15 per submission).
What are the risks of cracking a slab?▾
The main risks are: physical damage during cracking (scratches, dings, fingerprints), receiving a lower grade than expected, the card being deemed "altered" if cleaning residue or marks are detected, and loss of the original grade with no guarantee of matching or exceeding it. Always use a proper slab cracking tool, wear cotton gloves, and work on a clean soft surface. Never crack a card you cannot afford to lose value on.